Most of us put complete trust in the doctors, nurses and surgeons who treat us, and in the vast majority of cases that trust is well placed. The NHS and private healthcare providers deliver millions of successful treatments every year.
But sometimes things go wrong. A diagnosis is missed, a test result is overlooked, or a procedure leaves you worse off than before. When that happens, it can be hard to know whether you’ve simply been unlucky or whether the care you received fell short of what it should have been.
This guide explains what medical negligence actually means, the common situations where it arises, and the practical steps you can take if you think something has gone wrong with your treatment or the care of someone close to you.
What counts as medical negligence?
A bad outcome on its own doesn’t mean someone was negligent. Medicine carries risk, and some treatments don’t work as hoped even when everything is done properly.
In simple terms, negligence is when a healthcare professional provides care that falls below the standard you could reasonably expect, and that poor care causes you harm. To bring a claim, two things usually need to be shown:
- The care was below an acceptable standard. This is judged against what a responsible body of professionals in the same field would have done in the same situation.
- That poor care caused your injury or made it worse. This is often the trickier part. If you would have suffered the same harm anyway, a claim is unlikely to succeed, even if mistakes were made.
The two parts are often called “breach of duty” and “causation”. Both are normally assessed by independent medical experts before a claim goes any further.
Common examples
Negligence can happen in any setting, from a GP surgery or dental practice to a hospital ward, maternity unit or care home. Some of the situations that come up most often include:
- Misdiagnosis or delayed diagnosis, such as cancer, sepsis, stroke or a heart attack being missed or identified too late to treat effectively
- Surgical errors, including operating on the wrong site, damaging nerves or organs, or leaving equipment inside the body
- GP errors, such as failing to refer you to a specialist, missing abnormal test results or prescribing the wrong medication
- Birth injuries, affecting either the mother or the baby, often linked to poor monitoring during labour
- Medication and anaesthetic errors, including wrong doses or failing to check for known allergies
- Poor aftercare, such as infections or complications that weren’t spotted or acted on
If any of these sound familiar, it doesn’t automatically mean you have a claim. It does mean it’s worth asking questions.
Five steps to take if you think something went wrong
1. Look after your health first
Your wellbeing comes before anything else. If you’re still unwell or your symptoms are getting worse, get medical help straight away, whether that’s from your GP, NHS 111 or A&E. You’re entitled to ask for a second opinion, and seeking further treatment won’t harm any future claim.
2. Write down what happened while it’s fresh
Make a note of dates, appointments, the names of staff you saw, what you were told and how your symptoms developed. If family members were with you, ask them to do the same. Keep hold of letters, prescriptions, appointment cards and any receipts for costs you’ve had to cover, such as travel, parking or private treatment.
3. Ask for your medical records
You have a legal right to see your health records. You can request copies from your GP surgery or hospital through a subject access request, which is normally free and should usually be answered within one month. Your records can show what was recorded at each stage of your care and are often central to working out what went wrong.
4. Consider making a complaint
Raising a complaint with the hospital, GP practice or care provider can help you get an explanation and, in some cases, an apology. NHS complaints should usually be made within 12 months of the event, or of you becoming aware of it. If you’re unhappy with the response, you can take it to the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman in England.
It’s worth knowing that a complaint and a legal claim are separate. The complaints process can’t award compensation, and making a complaint doesn’t stop the clock on legal time limits.
5. Speak to a specialist solicitor
If you’ve been left with an injury, illness or financial loss, getting early advice from a solicitor who specialises in clinical negligence can help you understand whether you’re likely to have a claim. Many firms offer a free initial conversation, and a good solicitor will be honest with you if they don’t think a claim is likely to succeed.
Don’t leave it too long
There are strict time limits for medical negligence claims. In most cases, you have three years to start court proceedings. That three years runs either from the date of the negligence or from the date you first realised (or reasonably should have realised) that your injury may have been caused by poor care, which is known as the “date of knowledge”.
There are some important exceptions:
- Children have until their 21st birthday, as the three-year period only starts when they turn 18. A parent or guardian can bring a claim on their behalf before then.
- People who lack mental capacity aren’t bound by the time limit while that remains the case.
- Claims following a death generally need to be started within three years of the date of death, or of the date the family became aware negligence may have been involved.
Medical negligence cases take time to investigate, often involving records requests and expert reports, so getting advice well before the deadline gives you the best chance of your case being looked at properly.
How are claims usually paid for?
Cost is one of the biggest worries for people thinking about a claim. Legal aid is rarely available for medical negligence, except in some cases involving brain injuries to babies during pregnancy, birth or shortly after.
Most claims are funded through a no win, no fee arrangement, formally called a Conditional Fee Agreement. This generally means you won’t pay your solicitor’s fees if your claim is unsuccessful. If you do win, a success fee is taken from your compensation, but this is capped by law at 25% of certain parts of your damages. Insurance is usually arranged to cover other costs if the case is lost.
It’s also worth checking your home, car or bank account insurance policies, as some include legal expenses cover.
And if you’re worried about it affecting your future care: making a claim against the NHS won’t change the treatment you’re entitled to receive.
Choosing the right solicitor
Not every personal injury firm has the specialist knowledge that medical cases need. When you speak to a solicitor, it’s reasonable to ask:
- How many medical negligence cases have they handled, and of what type?
- Will you deal directly with the lawyer running your case, or be passed between different people?
- How will they keep you updated, and how quickly do they return calls?
- What will it cost if you win, and what happens if you lose?
- Will they arrange independent expert evidence before deciding whether to proceed?
A good solicitor should explain things clearly, be realistic about your chances and never pressure you into going ahead.
Getting answers matters
Finding out that your care may not have been what it should have been can be upsetting, frustrating and sometimes frightening. For many people, the goal isn’t just compensation. It’s getting a clear explanation of what happened, support with the financial impact on their lives, and some reassurance that lessons will be learned.
If you’re unsure where you stand, independent legal advice can help you understand your options without committing to anything. Firms such as Truth Legal offer a free initial consultation, giving you the chance to talk through what happened with an experienced lawyer and get an honest view on what to do next.
